J/ApJ/964/59  Gas-phase mass-metallicity relation for LEGA-C gal. (Lewis+, 2024)
================================================================================
The gas-phase mass-metallicity relation for massive galaxies at z~0.7
with the LEGA-C survey.
    Lewis Z.J., Andrews B.H., Bezanson R., Maseda M., Bell E.F., Dave R.,
    D'Eugenio F., Franx M., Gallazzi A., de Graaff A., Kaushal Y.,
    Nersesian A., Newman J.A., van der Wel A., Wu P.-F.
   <Astrophys. J., 964, 59 (2024)>
   =2024ApJ...964...59L
================================================================================
ADC_Keywords: Galaxies, spectra; Optical; Redshifts; Extinction; Abundances
Keywords: Galaxy abundances ; Metallicity ; Galaxy evolution

Abstract:
    The massive end of the gas-phase mass-metallicity relation (MZR) is a
    sensitive probe of active galactic nuclei (AGN) feedback that is a
    crucial but highly uncertain component of galaxy evolution models. In
    this paper, we extend the z~0.7 MZR by ~0.5dex up to
    log(M*/M_{sun}_)~11.1. We use extremely deep VLT VIMOS spectra from
    the Large Early Galaxy Astrophysics Census (LEGA-C) survey to measure
    metallicities for 145 galaxies. The LEGA-C MZR matches the
    normalization of the z~0.8 DEEP2 MZR where they overlap, so we combine
    the two to create an MZR spanning from 9.3 to 11.1 log(M*/M_{sun}_).
    The LEGA-C+DEEP2 MZR at z~0.7 is offset to slightly lower
    metallicities (0.05-0.13 dex) than the z~0 MZR, but it otherwise
    mirrors the established power-law rise at low/intermediate stellar
    masses and asymptotic flattening at high stellar masses. We compare
    the LEGA-C+DEEP2 MZR to the MZR from two cosmological simulations
    (IllustrisTNG and SIMBA), which predict qualitatively different
    metallicity trends for high-mass galaxies. This comparison highlights
    that our extended MZR provides a crucial observational constraint for
    galaxy evolution models in a mass regime where the MZR is very
    sensitive to choices about the implementation of AGN feedback.

Description:
    In this work, we take advantage of the ultra-deep spectra of a nearly
    mass-complete sample at 0.6<z<1.0 obtained by the Large Early Galaxy
    Astrophysics Census (LEGA-C; van der Wel+ 2016ApJS..223...29V;
    Straatman+ 2018, J/ApJS/239/27) survey.

    The LEGA-C survey used a K-band selection to target a nearly
    mass-selected sample of 3741 high-mass (M*>~10^10^M_{sun}_) galaxies
    with existing Ultra-VISTA photometry at z=0.6-1. The spectra were
    obtained with 20hr of integration time each on the Very Large
    Telescope (VLT) with the VIsible MultiObject Spectrograph (VIMOS) and
    resulted in spectra over the wavelength range 5800-9500{AA} with an
    average S/N of 20{AA}^-1^.

    Throughout this paper, we assume the following cosmology:
    H0=70km/s/Mpc, {Omega}_M_=0.3, and {Omega}_{Lambda}_=0.7.

File Summary:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 FileName   Lrecl  Records  Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ReadMe         80        .  This file
table1.dat     73      145  LEGA-C metallicities
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

See also:
 II/373 : The fourth UltraVISTA data release (DR4) (Moneti+, 2019)
 J/ApJ/617/240  : Oxygen abundances in the GOODS-North field (Kobulnicky+, 2004)
 J/MNRAS/404/1639 : MILES base models & new line index system (Vazdekis+, 2010)
 J/A+A/544/A156 : UltraVISTA Catalogue Release DR1 (McCracken+, 2012)
 J/ApJ/765/140  : Stacked spectra of SDSS star forming galaxies (Andrews+, 2013)
 J/ApJ/777/18   : Stellar mass functions of galaxies to z=4 (Muzzin+, 2013)
 J/ApJS/206/8   : COSMOS/UltraVISTA Ks-selected catalogs v4.1 (Muzzin+, 2013)
 J/MNRAS/469/2121 : Mass-metallicity relations with CALIFA (Sanchez+ 2017)
 J/ApJS/239/27  : LEGA-C DR2: galaxies in the COSMOS field (Straatman+, 2018)
 J/MNRAS/484/3042 : The gas-phase mass-metallicity relation (Sanchez+, 2019)
 J/ApJ/913/103  : SED modelling of LEGA-C & HST massive gal. (de Graaff+, 2021)
 J/ApJ/923/11   : Stellar kinematics of LEGA-C galaxies (van Houdt+, 2021)
 J/ApJ/927/164  : Stellar population properties from LEGA-C DR2 (Borghi+, 2022)
 J/ApJ/928/126  : Dynamical masses of z~0.8 gal. from LEGA-C (Straatman+, 2022)
 J/ApJS/256/44  : LEGA-C DR3: spectra of 0.6<z<1 gal. (van der Wel+, 2021)
 J/ApJ/936/9    : LEGA-C parameters for 877 galaxies (Van der Wel+, 2022)
 J/ApJ/961/118  : Star formation histories of LEGA-C galaxies (Kaushal+, 2024)
 J/A+A/708/A290 : LEGA-C stellar pop. scaling relations. II (Gallazzi+, 2026)

Byte-by-byte Description of file: table1.dat
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   Bytes Format Units    Label      Explanations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   1-  6 I6     ---      [MMS2013]  [6057/256256] Galaxy LEGA-C DR3 ID from
                                      van der Wel+ 2021, J/ApJS/256/44
   8- 10 I3     ---      Mask       [1/102] LEGA-C slit mask
  12- 17 F6.4   ---      z          [0.59/0.84] Spectroscopic redshift
  19- 23 F5.2   [Msun]   logMs      [9.8/11.1] Log of stellar mass
  25- 28 F4.2   ---      [OII]/Hb   [0.6/4.5] Dereddened [OII]3727 flux
                                     relative to H{beta}
  30- 33 F4.2   ---    e_[OII]/Hb   [0.02/0.8] Uncertainty in [OII]/Hb (1)
  35- 38 F4.2   ---      [OIII]/Hb  [0.05/1.9] Dereddened [OIII]5007 flux
                                     relative to H{beta}
  40- 43 F4.2   ---    e_[OIII]/Hb  [0.01/0.3] Uncertainty in [OIII]/Hb (1)
  45- 48 F4.2   mag      AV         [0.06/3.7] Nebular extinction, A_V_
  50- 53 F4.2   mag    e_AV         [0.04/1.01] Lower uncertainty on AV (1)
  55- 58 F4.2   mag    E_AV         [0.09/1.1] Upper uncertainty on AV (1)
  60- 63 F4.2   [-]      Metal      [8.49/9] Gas-phase metallicity, 12+log(O/H)
  65- 68 F4.2   [-]    e_Metal      [0.02/0.07] Lower uncertainty on Metal (1)
  70- 73 F4.2   [-]    E_Metal      [0.02/0.07] Upper uncertainty on Metal (1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note (1): Inner 68 percentile highest probability density interval from
    the MCMC posterior distribution.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

History:
    From electronic version of the journal

License: CC-BY-4.0

================================================================================
(End)                     Prepared by [AAS], Emmanuelle Perret [CDS] 02-Jun-2026
